May 10 2012

A Single Shard

Published by under Uncategorized

I think that what is happening right now in A Single Shard is interesting. I don’t fully understand what Kang did, but I wonder why Kim didn’t commend him. He may have had some things wrong with his vessel but if was a totally new idea that even Tree-ear thought was beautiful then I think it deserves some attention. I wonder what would happen if Kim might give both Kang and Min commissions. Would they work together, or would they work alone? In my opinion, they would work alone. If Min does get a commission will he try Kang’s new technique, or would he need help from Kang? If Min did do it would he be able to do it better than Kang? I think that Min might have an idea about Kang’s technique, but he probably wouldn’t know exactly how to do it because Kang didn’t tell anyone. I also wonder who they are trying to work for. Is it the emperor of China, or someone from Korea?

3 responses so far




3 Responses to “A Single Shard”

  1.   chrwa1213on 10 May 2012 at 3:57 pm

    Peter that was really insightful and it brought up good questions. Have you thought about what Tree-ear might do if he went along. Maybe the person might think Tree-ear is better than Kang and Min? Their is only one way to find out.

  2.   MBurrison 10 May 2012 at 7:15 pm

    You have several thought-provoking ideas here and some intriguing questions. It shows you are really thinking aboiut the book as you read! I can’t wait for you to see if your questions are answered.

  3.   wilbr1213on 10 May 2012 at 8:30 pm

    Peter, that is a great post! It is one of the best I have seen a kid write! You have an amazing talent on how to write blog posts! I really like this post because you were asking questions and you were answering some but leaving some for others to think about. I also had a similar prediction about Kang and Min both getting commissions. Great Post again. Come check my blog out!:) :)

Trackback URI | Comments RSS

Leave a Reply